The Old Map Critique & Discussion Thread

[Taley]

And yeah, what ever seems fit just put me somewhere. So I can update my news with a little more "accuracy" and actually RP.

I guess you have to chose between Danmarks spot and H12?

 

[Zoomany]

Well I guess that explains it all above. H12 is still the spot I'd like then.

 

[Khemia]

H12 seems a bit off for an fascist Eurodisney. Probably go over to where Europaland is at B3 and such. That continents like the extension of Europe.

 

[Khalistan]

Xen has already said no on H12, unless Zoomany changes his country's culture and history to work with the Himyar region.

 

[Polesia]

Maybe c9? Zoomany is Croatian yeah? Engellex had said Zadar-Istria is modelled on Croatia, and the surrounding nations are also Slavic.

 

[Khalistan]

At one time the sea between the Polascianan islands and Khalistan had a name of its own, but with the reload that name disappeared and the Long Sea has been applied to it. Now, my question is, is it part of the Long Sea or should it once again be given a name of its own?

 

[Great Engellex]

I think it should have a new name - for the purpose of better descriptions when wars are taking place.

 

[Khalistan]

I am of that opinion.

PS. I propose Sea of Sindh

 

[Anglyn]

I am of that opinion.

PS. I propose Sea of Sindh

Go with it.

 

[Tulus and Biminis]

Once the revamp is complete and I've got a spot I was wondering if I could get a large lake added to my spot, similar to Lake Baikal in Russia. This lake would be rather essential to my RP since it's climatic influences will greatly affect my agricultural industry and chemical industry.

 

[Josepania]

Nitpick: There appears to be a piece of Cambria still remaining on the map, while the main part of S3 has indeed been greened. I wonder, should it revert back to being part of S3, or made a micronation mapspot?

 

[Touzen]

Speaking of cities: imho, we could potentially lift the limit? It would significantly liven up the map, provided a city-free map is also provided.

 

[Josepania]

Speaking of cities: imho, we could potentially lift the limit? It would significantly liven up the map, provided a city-free map is also provided.

Obviously I support this in light of my recent city application. I suggest that the limit be what the mapmaker can fit onto the mapspot, so essentially a case-by-case basis. I, for example, can add a whole bunch more cities to my spot than, say, Nicosia in his spot.

 

[Khemia]

I could do with more than 3, I think. Though, I think cities are only useful if they're actually important, versus putting something like Dallas or Boston or Glasgow on a map.

 

[Touzen]

Murder City is pretty important!

 

[Mergogne]

Dallas, Boston, and Glasgow are all pretty important cities

 

[Khemia]

Important for all the wrong reasons!

 

[Tulus and Biminis]

So when is this so-called map revamp happening?

 

[Touzen]

When it's done.™

 

[Danmark]

That answers the question.