The Old Map Critique & Discussion Thread

[mrnutty]

FEAR THE GLORIOUS AND POWERFUL NATION OF mrnutty BWAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHA!!!

Seriously my ePene just shriveled a little bit.

But I recognize this as a temporary solution so I will not bitch to much, but it is the Nuttian Empire \o

 

[Thaumantica]

But I recognize this as a temporary solution so I will not bitch to much, but it is the Nuttian Empire \o

You are about to be fixed, as well as some other things I noticed.

If there is a next time, follow the application criteria:

Nation Name
Capital
Capital Location

 

[mrnutty]

Pfft. I am far too elitist for such things.

 

[Trans-Nineveh]

Superior in every way. Good job!

EDIT: If this map took you a few hours to make, then I'd say Sinhai's map can't be more than 10 minutes work.

 

[Chryse]

I dig it.

 

[Jydsken-Østveg]

No, I still plan on it... I'm just not complaining until I get all my history straightened out.

 

[Serenierre]

Nice map.

 

[Trans-Nineveh]

Nice map.

Yeah, just about anything's an improvement over that old rag. Funny how the alternative's better than the original.

 

[Thaumantica]

I dig it.

No, I still plan on it... I'm just not complaining until I get all my history straightened out.

Nice map.

Moved these posts. No disrespect to you's guys, but I want to keep the one map thread I have been allowed to moderate clear and concise, i.e. requests only so I do not miss anybody. And the next mapmaker has the bare essentials available to him or her.

 

[Josepania]

Eh, it's too pixelated for my taste, but since it's a supplement map that matters very little. It definitely does its job and I appreciate the effort you put into it.

 

[Caelia]

That new map feel.

I know that feel

btw it's just Kyiv now. Just FYI.

 

[Holy Frankish Empire]

ahhh, this feels good...like velour

 

[Arendaal]

Thanks for coming up with a solution, temporary or not

 

[Thaumantica]

Eh, it's too pixelated for my taste,

Yeah man, I did next to no redrawing. Coloring in the same place of a reused file detracts from quality significantly (ugly pixel shapes). Whenever we get off of these supplements, that person will have to do a detail of a lot of those islands.

 

[Aquitania]

No disrespect to Jose, but was it the intention of the mapmakers to allow so many of the Green Sea islands to come under the control of a single player, especially when that player also has a large mainland spot as well?

 

[Trans-Nineveh]

No disrespect to Jose, but was it the intention of the mapmakers to allow so many of the Green Sea islands to come under the control of a single player, especially when that player also has a large mainland spot as well?

Strong lungs and a very naughty look.

 

[Thaumantica]

No disrespect to Jose, but was it the intention of the mapmakers to allow so many of the Green Sea islands to come under the control of a single player, especially when that player also has a large mainland spot as well?

If Sinhai had any intent, he did not leave us a note or indication for us to consult, and if he did: point me to it.

Talk it over with Joe, if you decide through cooperative history that islands need to be exchanged/deleted/abandoned then very well, just work it in to RP.

 

[Warre]

Udo you missed quite a bit of my Boreasic pixels/didn't put them there. Look at the map [Bangkok] then look at SupplementK.

I want those removed pixels back.

 

[Trans-Nineveh]

I say we remove that ugly ass square in Himyar. This isn't anything official, just a lil' brainstorming.

You must be registered for see links

 

[Josepania]

No disrespect to Jose, but was it the intention of the mapmakers to allow so many of the Green Sea islands to come under the control of a single player, especially when that player also has a large mainland spot as well?

For the record, I did not talk to Sinhai or Catigny about how much of my current spot I could claim. I even said in my application that the amount of pixels I was claiming was what I assumed I could acquire. One of the major problems with Sinhai's maps were that empty plots were just not labeled and differentiated properly, so I took a gamble that I could claim a whole bunch of them and my request would be honored. This gamble was based off other map claiming efforts by other players that, more often than not, were honored by Sinhai. Going by the Supplement K map, that was not completely honored by Catigny, when looking at the northwestern islands, but I indicated to Catigny that I would work with that, no fuss or muss.

I am willing to work out with you a more reasonable number of Green Sea isles I can claim, but I'm curious. Why are you singling me out? Why aren't you calling out Akwesasne and his constant requests for a giant-ass spot, one way bigger than mine? One that, at the rate he's going, he's going to claim the entire continent he's on.